RANK

TOTAL GOALS

HOME TEAM

SCORELINE

AWAY TEAM

YEAR

1

11

Leyton Orient

9-2

Chester FC

1962

2

11

Wycombe

3-8

Aston Villa

2005

3

10

Bradford Park Avenue

7-3

Bradford City

1963

4

10

Workington AFC

9-1

Barrow AFC

1964

5

10

Derby County

6-4

Darlington

1967

6

10

Queens Park Rangers

8-2

Sheffield Wednesday

1973

7

10

Nottingham Forest

7-3

Watford

1982

8

10

West Ham United

10-0

Bury

1983

9

10

Wimbledon

6-4

Southend United

1983

10

10

Cardiff

6-4

Plymouth Argyle

1986

11

10

Liverpool

10-0

Fulham

1986

12

10

Barnet

5-5

Brentford

1991

13

10

Preston North End

6-4

Scarborough

1991

14

10

Aston Villa

6-4

Blackburn Rovers

2010

15

9

Southampton

5-4

Leeds United

1960

16

9

Tranmere Rovers

3-6

Middlesbrough

1961

17

9

Coventry City

1-8

Leicester City

1964

18

9

Chester FC

5-4

Derby County

1964

19

9

Tottenham Hotspur

6-3

Exeter City

1968

20

9

West Ham United

7-2

Bolton Wanderers

1968

21

9

Bolton Wanderers

6-3

Rochdale AFC

1969

22

9

Tottenham Hotspur

7-2

Doncaster Rovers

1975

23

9

Manchester United

7-2

Newcastle United

1976

24

9

Chesterfield

4-5

Charlton Athletic

1978

25

9

Queens Park Rangers

8-1

Crewe Alexandra

1983

26

9

Aston Villa

8-1

Exeter City

1985

27

9

Plymouth Argyle

3-6

Manchester City

1988

28

9

Luton Town

7-2

Mansfield Town

1989

29

9

Coventry City

5-4

Nottingham Forest

1990

30

9

Watford

3-6

Tottenham Hotspur

1994

31

9

Wimbledon

4-5

Charlton Athletic

1995

32

9

Stockport County

6-3

Mansfield Town

1997

33

9

Liverpool

3-6

Arsenal

2007

34

9

Norwich City

6-3

Bury

2013

35

9

Sunderland

6-3

Exeter City

2015

36

9

Manchester City

9-0

Burton Albion

2019

37

9

Lincoln City

2-7

Liverpool

2020